Incident Tracker / United States (state)
Dewald v. Massachusetts Mutual Life Ins. Co. (AI avatar at oral argument), App. Div. 1st Dept.
·New York Supreme Court, Appellate Division, First Department·US-STATEWarningunverified
Before New York's Appellate Division, First Department, self-represented appellant Jerome Dewald played an AI-generated avatar posing as his lawyer at his 26 March 2025 oral argument. The panel halted the video within seconds and he admitted it was AI-generated. He was verbally rebuked and allowed to continue in person; no sanction issued.
- Court
- New York Supreme Court, Appellate Division, First Department
- Date
- 2025-03-26
- Who used the AI
- Not recorded
- AI tool
- AI-generated video avatar (tool not named)
- Conduct
- A self-represented appellant obtained leave to play a prerecorded video for his oral argument, then played a generative-AI avatar of a fictional lawyer. The presiding justice stopped the video within seconds; the appellant admitted the presenter was AI-generated and was permitted to continue his argument in person.
- Outcome
- Warning
- Penalty
- No monetary penalty recorded
- Regulatory outcome
- No separate regulatory disposition recorded
- Status
- Unverified — pending primary-source confirmation
- Last checked
- 2026-09-04
Primary sources for this incident
Related regulation records for this incident
No related regulation record has been linked to this incident yet.
Similar incidents on the record
- State v. Presti, No. CAAP-24-0000826 (Haw. Ct. App.)2026-08-31 · Hawaii Intermediate Court of Appeals · WarningOn a Hawaii criminal appeal, self-represented appellant Cody Presti filed an opening brief citing 95 cases, 11 of which the court could not locate; six citations pointed to unrelated decisions. The Intermediate Court of…
- Noble v. WMC Mortgage Corp., 2026 IL App (1st) 251168-U2026-08-28 · Appellate Court of Illinois, First District · WarningIn Illinois, self-represented litigant Sanja Noble's mortgage appeal brief included a hallucinated citation to Ferguson v. Georges for the standard of review. The Appellate Court found the citation actually led to Peopl…
- Kiser v. DeSimone Auto Group, No. 2428 EDA 2025 (Pa. Super. Ct.)2026-08-27 · Superior Court of Pennsylvania · WarningIn Pennsylvania, counsel for Paige and Ty Kiser cited a non-existent Superior Court decision, Com. v. Reid, for an appellate issue in a consumer dispute. The Superior Court called the authority counterfeit, suggested ch…
- Salloum v. Department of Transportation, No. 25CA1748 (Colo. App.)2026-08-27 · Colorado Court of Appeals · WarningIn Colorado, self-represented appellant Ayman Salloum filed an opening brief citing three authorities the Court of Appeals could not verify, including one dated in the future. Applying Al-Hamim's warning on generative-A…
Cite this record
SafeLegalAI Global Legal AI Incident Tracker, “Dewald v. Massachusetts Mutual Life Ins. Co. (AI avatar at oral argument), App. Div. 1st Dept.”, safelegalai.com/tracker/dewald-ai-avatar (accessed 2026-09-16). Data: CC BY 4.0.